The verdict
Long-time users overwhelmingly dislike the reformulated version, citing a much stronger and unpleasant scent, thinner consistency, and reduced moisturizing ability compared to the classic formula.
What parents love
- • gentle moisturizer
- • works well
- • smooth texture
Worth knowing
- • new formula scent too strong
- • new formula feels sticky
- • new formula less creamy
- • new formula doesn't moisturize well
Beyond the listing
Parents and reviewers describe this as a gentle, long-established lotion that absorbs quickly and smells pleasant, though opinions split on moisturizing strength. Some find it insufficient for very dry skin or harsh climates, while others praise its effectiveness for daily use across the whole family and appreciate its accessibility and value.
Holds up elsewhere
- gentle on delicate skin
- absorbs quickly with no residue
- pleasant scent
- widely available and affordable
- good for sensitive or eczema-prone skin
Comes up as a drawback
- insufficient moisturizing for very dry skin
- not suitable for harsh winter climates
- strong scent may not suit all preferences
Safety check — clear
We cross-checked this product and its manufacturer against CPSC recall notices, NHTSA child-seat recalls, FDA recalls and the AAP's safe-sleep criteria on September 7, 2026, and found no active recall or safe-sleep concern. That is a check of the public recall record, not a test of the product.
Not sure you need this at all?
We take no commission on anything here, so we can say what most lists won't: a good deal of standard baby gear is skippable, borrowable, or actively discouraged by current safety guidance.
Read what we tell people to skip ›Rating and review themes are distilled from real Amazon customer reviews (shown only once a product has at least 7 ratings), last checked August 19, 2026. We carry no affiliate links and no brand pays to be featured — here's how we work.
Is this actually right for you?
This pick might not fit your home, your budget, or your climate. Answer a few quick questions and get a checklist matched to your actual family — free, no account needed.
Build my checklist